When you don't know where to turn...

You need an experienced team on your side!

  • Our legal team fights for justice & fair compensation
  • We won't stop until the negligent party is held responsible
  • You focus on getting better while we handle the details
Google Reviews Trantolo Law

85+

years

legal experience

Over $2B+

recovered in settlements & verdicts

24/7

convenience

award-winning client service

A+

rating

from 97.8% of clients

Personal Injury Attorney in Oyster Bay, NY

Free Legal Consultation

Call (844) 969-3238 24/7 or fill out this form with questions regarding your case.






    Life doesn’t stop after a serious injury. The bills continue to arrive. Your family still depends on you. At the same time, you’re expected to navigate medical appointments, insurance adjusters, and an uncertain recovery, all because someone else failed to act responsibly.

    You deserve the opportunity to focus on healing instead of fighting for the compensation you’re owed. An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney from Trantolo & Trantolo will stand by your side, protect your rights, and pursue the financial recovery you need to move forward. Fighting for the rights of injury victims since 1938, our team is ready to help. Reach out to Trantolo & Trantolo today to learn how we can support your recovery and your claim.

    Legal Representation for Many Types of Injury Claims 

    For more than 85 years, Trantolo & Trantolo has represented people whose lives were changed by someone else’s negligence. An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney from our team understands that every case presents unique legal and factual challenges, and we have the experience and resources to pursue claims across a wide range of practice areas, including:

    Motor Vehicle Accidents

    Even a crash that seems straightforward can quickly become complicated when injuries, disputed liability, or multiple insurance policies are involved. From rear-end collisions to intersection crashes, the financial and physical impact often extends well beyond the initial accident. Our  Oyster Bay car accident lawyers can help you understand your legal options after another driver’s negligence causes serious harm.

    Truck Accidents

    A collision with a commercial truck often results in more severe injuries and more complex legal questions than a typical car accident. Liability may extend beyond the truck driver to a trucking company, cargo loader, maintenance provider, or vehicle manufacturer. These claims frequently require a more extensive investigation than other motor vehicle accidents, and our Oyster Bay truck accident lawyers are ready to fight for what you need to recover.

    Motorcycle Accidents

    Motorcycle riders face unique risks every time they take the road. Without the protection of an enclosed vehicle, even a crash at moderate speeds can result in catastrophic injuries. Members of the Trantolo & Trantolo team are motorcycle riders themselves, giving our Oyster Bay motorcycle accident lawyers a firsthand understanding of the challenges riders face and the unfair assumptions they often encounter after a collision.

    Bicycle Accidents

    Bicyclists, including those riding e-bikes, have the same rights and responsibilities as other road users. Unfortunately, drivers don’t always respect bike lanes, check their blind spots, or yield before turning, placing cyclists at serious risk. Our Oyster Bay bicycle accident lawyers represent injured riders who have been harmed by negligent motorists and other preventable hazards.

    Pedestrian Accidents

    Pedestrians have little protection when a driver is distracted, speeding, or fails to yield. Crashes near crosswalks, parking lots, schools, and busy intersections can leave victims with life-altering injuries that require extensive treatment. Our Oyster Bay pedestrian injury attorneys help people injured on foot pursue compensation from the parties responsible for their losses.

    Dog Bite Lawyers

    A dog attack can cause lasting physical injuries and emotional trauma, particularly when a child is involved. Beyond emergency treatment, victims may face reconstructive procedures, permanent scarring, and anxiety long after the incident. Our Oyster Bay dog bite lawyers help clients understand their rights under New York law and pursue compensation when a dog owner’s negligence contributes to an attack.

    Slip and Fall Lawyers

    Our Oyster Bay slip and fall lawyers have seen firsthand how quickly property owners and insurance companies try to argue that a dangerous condition was “open and obvious” or that the injured person was somehow at fault. Our team is well-equipped to go up against these parties to fight for compensation that acknowledges your harm.

    "We believe in strong advocacy and personal attention for every client, drawing on decades of experience."
    Attorney Keith Trantolo

    What You Can Expect From Trantolo & Trantolo 

    Choosing the right legal team is about more than experience. You deserve an Oyster Bay personal injury attorney who will take the time to understand how your injuries have affected your life, explain your options clearly, and fight for the outcome you deserve. Since 1938, Trantolo & Trantolo has built its reputation by putting clients first and preparing every case with the care and attention it deserves.

    A Team That Knows You and Your Case

    After a serious injury, the last thing you need is to feel like another case file. That’s why Trantolo & Trantolo limits the number of cases we accept, allowing us to devote the time, attention, and resources each client deserves. From the beginning of your claim, you’ll work with a dedicated legal team that gets to know your circumstances, answers your questions, and remains available when you need guidance.

    Clear Communication From Start to Finish

    Legal claims can feel overwhelming when you don’t know what comes next. We believe you should never be left wondering where your case stands or what to expect. Our team keeps you informed throughout the process, explains important decisions in plain language, and makes sure your questions don’t go unanswered. When you have concerns, you’ll have a team that’s ready to listen and respond.

    A Commitment to Pursuing the Best Possible Outcome

    Insurance companies are focused on protecting their bottom line, not your future. Our attorneys build every case with the expectation that it could require litigation, allowing us to negotiate from a position of strength while remaining prepared to go to court when necessary. That commitment has helped Trantolo & Trantolo recover millions for injury victims throughout Long Island and Connecticut, and it continues to guide the way we advocate for every client.

    Reach out to Trantolo & Trantolo to learn how our team can help you move forward after a serious injury.

    What Compensation Can You Recover in an Oyster Bay Personal Injury Claim?

    No two personal injury claims have the same value because no two injuries affect people’s lives in the same way. The severity of your injuries, the length of your recovery, your ability to work, and the long-term impact on your daily life all influence the compensation available. An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney from Trantolo & Trantolo will evaluate every aspect of your losses to pursue compensation that reflects the full extent of your injuries, not just the expenses you’ve already incurred.

    Economic Damages

    Economic damages compensate you for the financial losses directly related to your injury. These damages are intended to reimburse both the costs you’ve already faced and the expenses you’re reasonably expected to incur in the future. Depending on your case, compensation may include:

    • Medical expenses, including hospitalization, surgery, rehabilitation, and future treatment
    • Lost wages and diminished earning capacity
    • Property damage related to the accident
    • Medical equipment, home modifications, or in-home care
    • Vocational rehabilitation or job retraining when an injury prevents you from returning to your previous occupation

    While medical bills and lost income are often the most obvious losses, they rarely tell the whole story. A serious injury can affect your earning potential for years, making it essential to account for future financial losses before accepting a settlement.

    Non-Economic Damages

    Some of the most significant consequences of a serious injury cannot be measured with receipts or invoices. Non-economic damages recognize the personal impact an injury has on your health, relationships, and overall quality of life. Depending on the circumstances, your claim may include compensation for:

    • Physical pain and suffering
    • Emotional distress
    • Loss of enjoyment of life
    • Permanent scarring or disfigurement
    • Loss of consortium when an injury affects a marital relationship

    These losses are deeply personal, but they deserve just as much consideration as your financial damages. Chronic pain, emotional trauma, and permanent limitations can affect nearly every aspect of your daily life, even after your physical injuries have healed.

    Evaluating the value of a personal injury claim requires more than adding up bills and receipts. Trantolo & Trantolo works to understand how your injuries have changed your life today and how they will continue to affect your future. By carefully documenting every category of damages, our team builds claims that reflect the full impact of your injuries, not just the losses that are easiest to measure.

    We Have a History of Fighting for Meaningful Results

    Over the years, Trantolo & Trantolo has secured significant recoveries for clients injured in a wide range of accidents, including a settlement for a client who suffered permanent brain injuries after a collision with a police vehicle and a multimillion-dollar recovery for a pedestrian struck while crossing the street. 

    While no attorney can promise a particular outcome, these results reflect the firm’s commitment to thoroughly preparing every case and fighting for the compensation each client deserves.

    Our Case Results

    $9,200,000

    Awarded

    Settlement during trial, after extensive discovery and litigation. Client developed cerebral palsy as a result of medical negligence which caused a lack of oxygen to the brain.

    $7,900,000

    Resolution

    Settlement after one week of trial. Client suffered permanent, severe brain damage when his vehicle was broadsided by a police car in pursuit of another vehicle.

    $3,500,000

    Resolved

    Client was riding on Route 15 in Meriden, Connecticut, when he traveled through an area of defectively milled roadway causing him to lose control of his motorcycle and crash. He and his wife settled a lawsuit with the defendant milling company, Black & Boucher LLC, for $3.5 million dollars.

    $3,000,000

    Awarded

    Client was struck by a left turning large truck while traveling straight on their motorcycle. The crash resulted in significant injuries and ultimately the death of the motorcyclist.

    $2,000,000

    Resolved

    Client was struck by a vehicle while crossing the street wearing a reflective vest. She suffered serious injuries requiring numerous surgeries and ongoing treatment.

    $1,550,000

    Awarded

    Client was a passenger in a motor vehicle involved in a car crash. Client suffered numerous serious injuries, including traumatic brain injury.

    $1,500,000

    Resolved

    Client was a passenger in vehicle driven by an intoxicated driver. Client suffered multiple injuries, including traumatic brain injury, when this car was involved in a one-vehicle accident.

    How Much Does it Cost to Hire a Personal Injury Lawyer?

    After a serious injury, it’s natural to worry about how you’ll pay your medical bills and keep up with everyday expenses. The thought of hiring an attorney can feel like one more financial burden, but it shouldn’t prevent you from protecting your rights.

    Trantolo & Trantolo handles personal injury claims on a contingency fee basis. That means you won’t pay any upfront attorney’s fees, and you won’t owe us anything unless we recover compensation on your behalf. We also offer free consultations, giving you the opportunity to discuss your case, understand your legal options, and decide what makes sense for your situation before making any financial commitment.

    Our goal is simple: make quality legal representation accessible when you need it most so you can focus on your recovery instead of worrying about the cost of pursuing a claim.

    How Long Do You Have to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in New York?

    The deadline for filing a personal injury lawsuit in New York is generally three years from the date of the injury, although certain circumstances can shorten or extend that timeframe. Because every case is different, speaking with an Oyster Bay personal injury attorney as soon as possible is the best way to understand the deadline that applies to your claim.

    Acting quickly is about more than meeting a legal deadline. Evidence can disappear, surveillance footage may be overwritten, accident scenes change, and witnesses’ memories naturally fade over time. Beginning an investigation early gives your legal team the best opportunity to preserve important evidence and build the strongest claim possible.

    If you’re unsure whether you still have time to pursue compensation, don’t assume you’ve missed your opportunity. Reaching out to Trantolo & Trantolo early allows our team to evaluate your case, explain your legal options, and help you avoid missing important deadlines.

    DON'T FIGHT SOLO.

    CALL US
    DON'T FIGHT SOLO

    What Should I Do After a Personal Injury in Oyster Bay?

    The hours and days after an accident can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re dealing with painful injuries and unexpected medical treatment. While every situation is different, the steps you take early on can affect both your recovery and your ability to pursue compensation. An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney can help protect your rights, but there are several important things you can do immediately after an accident.

    Seek Medical Attention Right Away

    Your health should always come first. Even if your injuries seem minor, it’s important to be evaluated by a medical professional as soon as possible. Some injuries don’t produce immediate symptoms, and delaying treatment can make it more difficult to connect your injuries to the accident later.

    Report the Accident and Gather Information

    Notify the appropriate authorities whenever required, such as calling the police after a motor vehicle accident or reporting a hazardous condition to a property owner or business. If you’re able, collect photographs of the scene, your injuries, and any property damage. You should also obtain contact information for witnesses and anyone else involved in the incident.

    Follow Your Treatment Plan

    Attending follow-up appointments, participating in physical therapy, and following your doctor’s recommendations all support your recovery. They also help create a clear record of how your injuries have affected you over time, which can become important evidence in your claim.

    Be Careful When Speaking With Insurance Companies

    Insurance adjusters often contact injured people soon after an accident. While they may seem helpful, their goal is to evaluate the claim on behalf of the insurance company. Before providing a recorded statement or accepting a settlement offer, make sure you understand your rights and the full extent of your injuries.

    Preserve Any Evidence Related to Your Claim

    Keep copies of medical records, receipts, repair estimates, correspondence, and any other documents related to the accident. The more information you preserve, the easier it will be to demonstrate how the injury has affected your health, finances, and daily life.

    No one expects to find themselves dealing with the aftermath of a serious injury. By protecting your health, preserving important evidence, and understanding your legal rights from the beginning, you’ll be in a stronger position to move forward, whatever your recovery may require. 

    Let’s win your case TOGETHER

    DON'T FIGHT SOLO.

    CALL US

    Start Your Recovery With Trantolo & Trantolo

    The outcome of your personal injury claim can affect your recovery for years to come. Having the right legal team by your side means having advocates who are prepared to protect your interests, challenge the insurance company when necessary, and pursue the compensation your injuries warrant.

    An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney with Trantolo & Trantolo is ready to answer your questions, explain your options, and help you take the next step with confidence. Reach out today to schedule your free case review.

    Oyster Bay Personal Injury FAQs

    What Happens if I Was Partially at Fault for the Incident?

    New York law allows injured parties to seek compensation when they share fault, although the circumstances of your claim can determine the threshold of shared responsibility and potential compensation.

    It’s also common for insurance companies to argue that an injured person shares some of the blame for an accident. Whether that argument is supported by the evidence depends on the circumstances of your case. An Oyster Bay personal injury attorney with Trantolo & Trantolo can evaluate what happened, explain your legal options, and help you understand whether you still have a claim.

    How Long Does It Take to Resolve a Personal Injury Case?

    Every personal injury claim follows a different timeline. Factors such as the severity of your injuries, the length of your medical treatment, the complexity of the evidence, and whether a fair settlement can be reached all influence how long a case takes to resolve. While some claims conclude within months, others require additional time to ensure the full extent of your damages is understood before negotiations or litigation move forward.

    Will I Have to Go to Court for My Personal Injury Claim?

    Not necessarily. Most personal injury claims do not need to go to trial, but are resolved through settlement negotiations. However, if an insurance company refuses to offer fair compensation, taking the case to court may become the best path forward. Trantolo & Trantolo prepares every case as though it could proceed to trial, allowing our attorneys to negotiate from a position of strength while remaining ready to advocate for you in court if necessary.